Rats, foiled again

More often than not, I come up with a great gift for Jay only to have him guess what it is before I ever even get it wrapped! It is very frustrating to me because I always feel like Jay just thinks I am buying him what he asked for, but most of the time I already have it bought! This year, I have a great idea and have been shopping for the best deal on it since August. Jay comes to me last month and says "if anyone is looking to get me a gift..." and of course it was the gift I planned on getting him. It really takes the fun out of giving a gift if someone has already guessed what I am giving them...